The post
Most people treat Reddit like social media: post, get a spike, move on. My data says it works more like SEO.
**Context:** I run a small insurance affiliate site. Every link I post in a Reddit comment has its own tracking tag (subreddit + thread + device + button), so every sale traces back to one specific comment. In 2025, comments brought 461 conversions, about $12K.
**The part that surprised me:**
\- About **three-quarters** of my tagged Reddit revenue in 2025 came from **threads created in 2024 or earlier**.
\- One car detailing thread from mid-2024 brought conversions in **11 of 12 months** of 2025.
\- A handyman thread from **late 2022** was still converting in 2025.
Why: a good thread keeps getting found. People search Reddit (and Google, which shows a lot of Reddit now) for the same question months later, read the top answers, and click. A helpful comment is basically a page that ranks.
**What this changes about how I do it:**
1. **Write for the reader who shows up in a year, not just the OP.** Complete answer, real numbers, nothing that dates fast.
2. **Don't hunt for the perfect sub**. Volume of good answers beats sub selection.
3. \*\*Search all of Reddit for the question, not a list of subs.\*\* My hand-picked sub list missed most of the threads that ended up paying.
4. **Tag every link per thread**. Without it, you'll never see the compounding. I lost my first year of data by not doing this.
Not naming the subs on purpose. I build marketing tools (app.talkgen.ai), but no link here; this is just the data.
Has anyone else measured how long a Reddit thread keeps paying? Curious if it's this long-tailed outside insurance.
View the original thread on Reddit →