The post
Not a guide, just an experiment with real numbers. I'm a solo founder with one paying user, and I used Reddit mostly for feedback.
Setup
\- 12 posts in 12 subreddits over two days. Four of them had a link to the site.
\- Most had their own angle: pricing, a technical problem, positioning, UX. Two were the same announcement in two subs.
What got comments (from other people, counted about 3 days later)
\- The two "I built X" announcement posts: 0.
\- The other 9 that stayed up: 3 to 12 each. The best were "here's my pricing with 1 paying user, roast it" (11) and "random learning vs. goal-based learning, which do people pay for?" (12).
\- One post was removed because I didn't read the subreddit's rules. My fault.
\- 59 comments from other people in total. Together with replies to my comments in other threads, the useful advice fell into 8 themes. The biggest one (16 people, a few disagreeing): sell an outcome, not a habit.
What got traffic
\- Before: about 6 visitors a day.
\- The day after the first posts: 57. Then 24 and 17. By day four, it was back to 5.
\- On the two busiest days, 84% of visitors left after one page, and onboarding was opened 4 times.
\- Only 5 of those 81 visitors had Reddit as the referrer. Most showed up as direct or came from other sources.
What I can't measure
Whether any of it turned into users. Reddit usernames don't map to signups, and most of the traffic has no referrer.
**Questions**:
1. How do you attribute Reddit traffic when most of it lands as direct? Links get removed in a lot of subs, so UTMs aren't always an option.
2. Is "comments I'd actually act on" a fair metric at this stage, or am I fooling myself?
View the original thread on Reddit →