ThreadPilot
Founder Operator
r/DigitalMarketingHackPosted Oct 13, 2026

I ran a lead gen agency on 15 hours a week of manual prospecting. Here’s what i would change

by u/EntertainmentNew9556 · 2 upvotes · 17 comments

The post

Last year I had a lead gen agency and two VAs, and I was still doing 12-hour days of follow-ups and qualifying calls. Most of those calls went nowhere: no budget, or not the person who decides. If I started again, this is what I'd change. 1. I'd pick a niche I can search for. If you can't type the niche into a search bar and get a list of businesses, prospecting stays manual forever. "Med spas in Texas" works. "Founders who value growth" doesn't. 2. I'd stop paying VAs to send templates. Mine sent hundreds of near-identical messages and the reply rate showed it. One message written from the prospect's own bio beat ten templates. 3. I'd qualify in the DM, not on the call. One question before booking ("are you handling bookings yourself or does someone run that?") would have cut half my dead calls. 4. I'd track four numbers from day one: reply rate, positive reply rate, conversation rate and booking rate. I didn't, so I couldn't tell whether the targeting or the message was the problem. Going from 20 tire-kickers a week to 5 to 7 calls with people who wanted what I sold changed the job more than any new offer did. I eventually automated most of this into a tool for myself, approval step included, because I didn't trust anything sending in my name unchecked. At the moment there is a 3-day free trial for agency owners.
View the original thread on Reddit →

Why this is an opportunity

  • ✓Discusses manual prospecting and lead qualification, but not finding buyers on Reddit
  • ✓Shares lessons from running a lead gen agency without asking for a solution
  • ✓Specific experience with VAs, templated outreach, and unqualified calls
  • ✓Posted about 26 days ago, with 2 upvotes and 17 comments

Never miss a thread like this again

ThreadPilot finds Reddit posts where people ask for products like yours, scores them, and drafts a helpful reply.

Try ThreadPilot free