ThreadPilot
Solution Seeking
r/founderPosted Nov 11, 2026

I tagged every promo link for my Mac app for 30 days: 88 actions, 24 visits, 0 sales. 5 of my 30 orders trace back to Google, and 22 to nothing at all

by u/DutyOnly4308 · 1 upvotes · 0 comments

The post

I'm a solo founder from France and I make Mac+, a paid macOS app for animated wallpapers and desktop widgets (it has a free version too). Every number below comes from my analytics and from Polar, my payment provider, read today (Nov 11). Last month, under a post I wrote here, someone asked which channel brings my paying users, and whether it's the one I put the most time into. I didn't have a real answer. A lot of my marketing time goes into posting and replying in communities, so every link I post for the app now gets its own tag: one utm_campaign per post, reply or directory listing, not one per platform. The last 30 days: - 88 tagged actions (posts, replies, blog comments, listings): 24 visits, 0 sales. The best were 3 Threads posts, with 9 visits. 7 Reddit posts and replies brought 4. 29 blog comments brought 3. - 2,949 visitors to the site overall, 1,778 of them from organic search. - 30 orders: 5 tied to a visit that came from Google, 3 to a direct visit, and 22 with no visit I can tie them to. So, to that question: no, it's not the same channel. At least not that I can see. What the orders I can trace look like. On Nov 10, someone in France searched on Google, landed on my French page "Fond d'écran animé pour Mac" (animated wallpaper for Mac), looked at 5 pages and bought Pro. The visit started at 18:39 UTC and the order came in at 18:46. One order on Nov 9 and one on Nov 6 started on that same page, from Google, from France. None of the orders I can trace started from a post. What I'd pass on if you sell a cheap consumer app: 1. Tag each action, not each platform. "reddit" as a source told me nothing. Per-post tags showed me that 36 of my 88 actions got no visit at all. 2. For each sale, look at the page the buyer entered on, not just the channel. The ones above started on a page that answers one search, in the buyer's own language, not on my homepage. 3. Treat "no source" as the main line, not a footnote. Could be tracker blockers, people who try the free version and come back later to buy, or gaps in my own setup. I don't know the split yet, so I don't read much into the orders I can trace. 4. Go where someone is already asking. For my other product, the only Reddit link that sold anything in the last 30 days was a reply in a thread where someone asked for exactly that kind of tool. My best Reddit posts for it got 2 visits each. The app, since this is r/founder: Mac+ runs from the menu bar on macOS 13 or later. The free version has 6 animated scenes, 8 palettes and 2 widgets, and works across several displays. Pro adds the other scenes, your own video as wallpaper and all 12 widgets, for €1.99/month after a 7-day trial (it takes a card, nothing is charged for 7 days) or €8.99 once with the Christmas offer. You need an account to buy, and there's no Christmas scene, just a Snow one. Site: [macplus.pro](https://macplus.pro/?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=post&utm_campaign=jv-lnyczk) If you sell a consumer app: how much of your revenue can you actually tie to a source, and what did you change once you saw it?
View the original thread on Reddit →

Why this is an opportunity

  • ✓Posted recently
  • ✓Low comment competition

More opportunities in r/founder

Never miss a thread like this again

ThreadPilot finds Reddit posts where people ask for products like yours, scores them, and drafts a helpful reply.

Try ThreadPilot free