The post
Hello. I have a full length book coming out in a year about Augusta Britt and her relationship with Cormac and I am going to do an AMA on here around the time of its release. You may ask me whatever you like and I will answer. I have come to understand a lot of you guys do not like me, though I've had great conversations with many of you in the past on this forum several years ago. I also greatly enjoyed reading your reactions to my Vanity Fair profile.
In the meantime, I'd like to clear up some misconceptions that Tracy Daugherty's biography is popularizing. I've spoken many times in the last few years with Tracy and find him a good man. Some parts of his biography are very well researched, and culminate in an interesting portrait of Cormac. However, some things he gets very wrong and I'd like for you all not to be led astray.
1. Stella Maris was not excised out of The Passenger. Based as it is on Cormac's obsession with Augusta's psychiatric appointments (which he procured for her and paid for at the time of her suicide attempt, but which he could not be party to), Cormac sent Augusta a lovingly addressed copy of Stella Maris SEVERAL YEARS before its publication and before Cormac's serious decline in health. I have read it and it is almost entirely identical to the finished, published version. As Augusta refused to talk to Tracy, he had no access to this ms, though Glenn Horowitz did share with him the fact that it is included in Augusta's private possession. The newly made public materials in the archive show no master manuscript from which SM could later have been excised or evidence that it was, and these materials were sold to Texas State and itemized a decade and a half before Cormac's death. When one sifts through the new material, including drafts for unfinished works and the thousands of pages of Cormac's notes -- some dated, some whose dates are ascertainable through context clues -- the genesis of Stella Maris is clear. It began as a project called The Witness in small memo pad notes dated to the months after Augusta broke Cormac's heart, and subsequently entered of a psych ward, as well as some larger typewritten pages. There are varying and contradictory storylines in The Witness, but some papers show a man bereaved and heartbroken at the death of his wife, who then enters a series of long conversations between himself and a psychiatrist. This project idea is eventually abandoned and Cormac writes a draft called The Child of the Times, in which a man with a mysterious mental illness has a conversation with a psychiatrist, very similar in content to Stella Maris. Concurrent with this, Cormac was beginning to draft The Passenger, whose first complete draft in the Witliff is remarkably more coherent and enjoyable a novel than the finished product. I won't go into that here, but it contains many more scenes between Bobby and Alicia in Tucson that match Augusta's account (not all of which I have so far published) of her post-breakup experience in Tucson with Cormac; Cormac's journals and notes (some of which are in private possession, some of which are in the Witliff and require many hours and days to make one's way through but are there for the serious reader); and letters between the two. In conclusion, the speculation made by Daugherty is entirely wrong and bears itself out in the archives. It does not include Stella Maris scenes. There are occasionally numbered pages missing, but the frequency is mostly anomalous and does not support a structure in which Stella Maris is interlayered into The Passenger. Even if it was, this manuscript is quite weathered and old and typewritten -- this would not support the speculative narrative that Stella Maris and The Passenger were hastily assembled. McCarthy worked on The Passenger for over forty years. If he'd kept it closer to the state its full draft is in in the Witliff, it would be much more successful and timely. I'll keep that last part mysterious for now.
2. Daugherty had no access to Augusta or to Cormac's surviving closest friends in Tucson. Without access, almost the entirety of his material on Augusta comes from my article. In lieu of Augusta, Tracy tries to paint Cormac as a horndog who was into younger women. He did run off with a friend of his wife in the mid-70s named Eve (who was in her 20s and whom Guy Davenport euphemistically and disparagingly referred to as a teenage popsie, leading some who questioned my reporting to then run away with the absolutely untrue claim that Augusta must have been 14 when they ran away -- not true), but a horndog after young women is a total mischaracterization. His closest intimates still alive have all described him to me as almost curiously chaste in conversation and action. He had weekend girlfriends he'd go to the movies with or dinner, but he was a man on the road dedicated to his craft and did not socialize during the week, and was not always in the same place by the weekend. People dated much more frequently back then in the late 70s and 80s. It's not like today with Tinder and other apps. The frequency one went to a dinner and a movie with someone was not particularly redolent of one's libido -- it was part of being social. In lieu of Augusta, I find that Tracy plays up miscellaneous details of Cormac's subtle dating history to try and round out a personal portrait. All through this period Cormac was quite dedicated to Augusta and bent on trying to fix her and get her back. These are laid to bare in his letters to her, and in personal testimony of his Tucson friends.
3. Cormac McCarthy did not commit statutory rape, contrary to Tracy's claim. Augusta was 17 at the time they first consummated their relationship in New Mexico, the same age as the age of consent. (This too is corroborated in Cormac's personal notes in the Witliff -- in a note to himself he dates '77 as the year they run away and arrive in Lordsburg, New Mexico and where they first make love. Augusta was 17 in the spring of 77 when they left, which is confirmed by her testimony and others', and most conclusively the dating of the last letter Cormac sent to her in Tucson before they ran away in May of 77, and another piece of evidence I cannot at this time mention -- sorry.) What Cormac was guilty of was violating the Mann Act. It was Augusta who supplied me with details about the FBI being interested in finding her, as this is of course a very serious federal crime -- not Cormac making her think they were in danger as Tracy pulls out of absolutely nowhere, and is quite a careless mischaracterization.
4. Finally, for now, Tracy takes a sentence from a letter Cormac wrote in the mid to late 80s (after Augusta had already left him and married someone else and their relationship therefore had changed dramatically) wherein Cormac says, to this effect and in relation to Augusta, "I don't know if I want to be with someone with such mental troubles," and then applies this to the late 70s when they'd returned from Mexico and were living in the South, misstating that Cormac was having romantic doubts about Augusta nearly ten years before he did. Glenn Horowitz, without permission, allowed Tracy to read Cormac's letters to Augusta. They are the letters of a depressed man desperate to have Augusta back, desperate to help her. The notes and journals in the Witliff further expand this. Tracy's projection of a quote from 1985 (?) relaying a feeling from 1985 to a relationship as it stood in 1978 is very sloppy, and speaks to my overall assessment that being denied access to Augusta, he downplayed her.
That's it for now. I look forward to talking to you more in depth when my book comes out. In the meantime, the Witliff is an amazing source of public corroboration for many of the claims Augusta made (and which we had already fact checked successfully against private documents and sources amongst Cormac's intimates and family who wished to remain silent publicly). The only caveat is you have to be willing to spend considerable time poring through documents and reading every single messily handwritten note Cormac ever made. If you can afford to go, however, I recommend it.
Thank you.
View the original thread on Reddit →