The post
I'm a builder, not a marketer. When I launched my last product I figured Reddit would be easy: find people in my niche, send a friendly DM, done.
It wasn't. I picked people based on which subreddit they hung out in, not on what they'd actually said. My messages were polite and completely generic. Reply rate was close to zero, and most of the replies I did get were "how did you get my username?"
The turning point was embarrassingly simple. I stopped messaging people who *might* need my product and only messaged people who had publicly described the exact problem in the last few days. Before DMing, I'd leave a real answer in their thread. Then the DM referenced what they wrote.
Replies went up right away. The conversations started to feel real. Some of them turned into customers.
The problem: doing this by hand ate \[2 hours\] a day. Searching, reading threads, judging fit, keeping my account active enough not to look like a burner. So I built Scaloom to handle the grind while I stay the one who hits send.
How it works:
1. **It finds the leads.** It watches the subreddits you care about and surfaces people talking about the problem you solve, with the thread and a short reason each one is a fit.
2. **It finds the comment openings.** Buyer questions where a helpful reply makes sense, so you show up in public first.
3. **It drafts the DM.** A personalized first message based on their post. I read every one, tweak it, and decide who gets it. Nothing gets sent automatically.
4. **It keeps the account healthy.** Warmup builds karma and normal activity in the background, or you can post from our high-karma accounts while yours warms up.
5. **It runs the content side on autopilot.** Post ideas from what's already working in your niche, a weekly plan, scheduling across subreddits, auto-replies, and rule/promo-risk checks before anything goes live. A human still validates before it publishes.
What I'd tell anyone doing Reddit outreach, with or without a tool:
\-> Intent beats targeting. "Posts in r/startups" is not a lead. "Asked yesterday how to fix X" is.
\-> Be visible before you're in someone's inbox.
\-> Never send a DM you wouldn't be fine with them screenshotting.
\-> Honest caveat: this approach gets you fewer conversations, not more. They're just much better ones.
If you want to try the same workflow without the spreadsheets, give [scaloom.com](http://scaloom.com) a try.
Would love feedback from this sub, especially the brutal kind.
View the original thread on Reddit →