The post
#
We often focus on which brands AI recommends. But there's another question worth investigating:
**If someone asks the same buying question in three different ways, does AI rely on the same sources each time?**
We put together a simple test to explore this.
# The experiment
We used three versions of a buying question:
1. "What are the best AI visibility tools?"
2. "Which AI visibility tool is best for a small marketing agency?"
3. "What are the best affordable tools to track brand mentions in ChatGPT?"
We wanted to compare the responses across ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini.
# What we wanted to examine
* Do the same brands appear across all three prompts?
* Do the cited websites change when the buyer's requirements become more specific?
* Do comparison articles, reviews, and third-party discussions appear more often?
* Does a brand disappear when the use case or budget changes?
* Are some sources consistently cited across different buying questions?
# Why this matters
A brand might have strong visibility for a broad category query but very little visibility for a specific buyer requirement.
That means looking at one generic prompt may give an incomplete picture of how potential customers actually discover a product.
**Our takeaway:** AI Visibility shouldn't be evaluated only at the category level. Buyer intent, prompt wording, competitors, and cited sources all deserve separate attention.
# A question for the community:
Have you noticed AI platforms changing their cited sources when you add details such as budget, company size, or a specific use case?
And do you track source visibility separately for different buyer-intent categories?
View the original thread on Reddit →