ThreadPilot
Informational
r/lemlist_officialPosted Oct 6, 2026

What reply rate should I expect from cold outbound?

by u/sent_from_lemlist · 2 upvotes · 1 comments

The post

Short answer: reply rate is the metric that matters, open rate is a weak signal, and click rate is a red herring. Below are benchmarks from lemlist data (244,000+ campaigns, 249M+ emails) so you can see where you stand. **Reply rate per campaign (email only)** - Under 2%: something is broken (list, copy or deliverability) - 2 to 4%: average - 4 to 10%: good - 15% and up: really good - 25% and up: exceptional, almost always a tight list plus sharp copy **Global reply rate by channel mix** - Email only: 1.1% - LinkedIn + email: 4.7% - LinkedIn-first sequences: 5.7% - Email-first sequences: 2.6% Starting with LinkedIn instead of email more than doubles the global reply rate. Biggest structural lever available. **Global reply rate by list size** - 6 to 50 leads: 5.3% - 51 to 200 leads: 3.2% - 201 to 500 leads: 2.3% - 501 to 1,000 leads: 1.9% - 1,000+ leads: 1.1% Bigger lists mean broader targeting and less relevant messages. Split one large campaign into several tight segments instead. **Positive reply rate (the one tied to pipeline)** - Industry average: 0.1 to 0.5%, so 1 to 5 meetings per 1,000 emails - Good: 1 to 5% - Exceptional: more than 5 meetings per 100 leads A high reply rate with a low positive reply rate means people reply to disengage ("wrong person", "remove me"). Fix targeting and your call to action, not your volume. **Open rate: use with caution** Open tracking needs a pixel, and pixels hurt deliverability. Some email clients also pre-load images and fake opens, others block tracking entirely. Typical open rates if you still track them: - Global average: around 25% - C-levels and marketing: around 15% - Sales and HR: 25 to 35% - Tech profiles: around 5% - 50% and up: strong subject line **Click rate: don't track it** Links in cold emails hurt deliverability, and clicks don't correlate with pipeline. Remove links from first touches. If you need one, send people to a landing page and measure traffic there. **How to read your numbers together** - High opens + low replies: subject line works, body doesn't. Rewrite the first two lines and the call to action. - Low opens + low replies: deliverability or subject line issue. Check deliverability first. - Good replies + few meetings: wrong persona or wrong ask. - Great results on small lists, falling apart at scale: expected. Keep lists tight. **What to track every week** - Reply rate per campaign - Positive reply rate, or meetings booked per 100 leads - Bounce rate as a list health check - LinkedIn acceptance rate if you run LinkedIn steps Share your numbers and context (persona, list size, channels) in the comments and we'll tell you where you stand.
View the original thread on Reddit →

Why this is an opportunity

  • ✓Shares cold outbound reply-rate benchmarks across email and LinkedIn
  • ✓Explains outreach performance but does not ask for a solution or tool
  • ✓Posted about two days ago, with 2 upvotes and 1 comment
  • ✓Relevant sales audience, though the poster's role and company are unclear

Never miss a thread like this again

ThreadPilot finds Reddit posts where people ask for products like yours, scores them, and drafts a helpful reply.

Try ThreadPilot free