The post
I know 38 emails is still a very small sample, especially because I’m only just starting to ramp the infrastructure slowly.
What’s worrying me is the contrast with the previous days. Even when I was only sending 10–15 emails, I would usually get at least some kind of feedback: an out of office, a negative reply, something.
Today I sent 38 and got absolutely nothing back. No replies, no negative replies, no OOO, no auto responses. Just complete silence.
SPF, DKIM and DMARC are all set up correctly and passing, and I’m confident the basic authentication side is fine.
That’s why I’m starting to wonder whether the problem is more about inbox placement, domain or mailbox reputation, or possibly the copy being filtered.
I can send tests to inboxes I control, but I’m not sure how representative those tests really are compared with what’s happening with actual prospects.
I keep seeing conflicting advice about inbox placement tests, warmup, domain reputation, copy fingerprinting, Microsoft vs Google, and reply rate as a signal, so I’m struggling to work out what I should actually trust.
At this point I’m mainly trying to understand how to properly diagnose whether the emails are reaching the inbox, going to spam, or whether this is simply normal variance from a small sample.
Happy to share more details privately if useful.
View the original thread on Reddit →