The post
Hey everyone,
I’m pretty new to cold email and I honestly don’t know where to go from here, so I’d really appreciate some help from people who have more experience with deliverability.
I currently have one Microsoft 365 inbox that I *think* is landing in the inbox, but I’m not even 100% sure because I don’t know which seed/inbox placement tests I can actually trust. Mail-Tester says everything is configured correctly and doesn’t show any obvious issues.
Then I have another inbox using private SMTP with Namecheap. At first, emails from it were landing in the inbox, but now they consistently go to spam on Microsoft. I’ve had it in warm-up for around two and a half weeks, with no campaigns running, and it still goes to spam even if I send something as simple as:
“Hi, how are you?”
I also have a Google Workspace inbox on a domain that’s about a year old. That inbox hasn’t been used for outreach either. It has only been warming up for around two and a half weeks, but emails from that account also go to spam on Microsoft, even with completely normal, non-commercial messages.
On top of that, I bought five private SMTP inboxes from Lead Gen J because I’d heard they were supposed to be very good for deliverability.
They’ve also been warming up for about two weeks with zero campaigns sent.
I tested one of them by manually sending a very basic email to a Microsoft 365 inbox that I own, and it went straight to spam as well.
This is the part I really don’t understand.
I haven’t been blasting thousands of emails or running huge campaigns. My outreach volume has always been very low. Yet it feels like almost every new inbox or sending setup I test eventually ends up in Microsoft spam, sometimes before I’ve even used it for outreach.
At this point I don’t know whether the problem is the domains, the sending IPs, the warm-up providers, Microsoft itself, or whether the seed tests I’m using are giving me a false sense of security.
If anyone has dealt with something similar, I’d really appreciate some guidance on what I should actually be checking and how you would diagnose this.
Especially:
Which inbox placement/seed tests do you actually trust for Microsoft 365?
Could private/shared SMTP IP reputation be causing this even on brand new inboxes?
Is two and a half weeks of warm-up simply not enough?
What would you do next if even completely normal emails are landing in spam?
I’m genuinely stuck, so any advice would be really appreciated.
View the original thread on Reddit →